top of page

What People are Saying....

As the co-creater and co-executive producer of Food Network's "Ace of Cakes" I've been fortunate enough to try sweet treats and baked goods from all over the world, and Cafe Everyday Sunday are some of the absolute best. Caitlin really does bake her treats with love and it shows - not only do they taste great, but you can tell she really cares in getting all the custom details exactly right. Highly recommended and I'm already looking forward to placing another order...!

     - Willie Goldman

Everyday Sunday managed to feed an entire, hungry, cranky Colony TV crew at the end of a long week of shooting. Not an easy task. But the delicious cookies buoyed their spirits and got them through the week. Thank you, Caitlin!

     - Ryan Condal

I HIGHLY recommend Cafe Everyday Sunday for any special event you need a delicious/gorgeous treat!! I completely omitted the cake for my wedding and had a cookie bar instead!!! The cookies were amazing and people could not stop eating them!!! Every flavor we ordered was UNBELIEVABLE. Thank you Caitlin for making my cookie bar memorable! The cookies were the talk of the night!!!

     - Sara Sanderson

I had a champagne brunch for my birthday last spring and I wanted to impress some of Hollywood's top casting director friends of mine. I knew just who to call in order to have some amazing tasting desserts that were well presented and gave my party that expensive feel without breaking the bank.

     - Holland Weathers

I have a big Christmas party every year. This year we had Cafe Everyday Sunday do all our cookies for it. And they were a huge hit, beautiful and very yummy everyone loved them and were amazed by how beautiful and festive they looked. I can't thank you enough! definitely going to be ordering more very soon!

      - Ruth Dennis Geier

Cafe Everyday Sunday operates on passion and love. The first experience I had with them, it was clearly evident. The attention to detail and care for customers is second to none. Every step of the process as a customer; I could not be more please. From presentation, to quality, and taste, you cannot go wrong. Do yourself a favor and check out some of these amazing treats!

     - Justin Stearns

Caitlin’s deserts are one of a kind. I’m a realtor and hired her for all of my open houses and can happily say, her tasty treats helped create a welcoming atmosphere for passing patrons to feel right at home. The response was always positive as the flavor and presentation was loved by all.

     - Peter DiVito


Caitlin catered my daughter's 1st birthday party and everything was delicious! Her Oreo pops are adorable, the chocolate covered caramel apples are so impressive and the home made cupcakes are always a big hit! Great customer service. Excellent product. Timely delivery. What more can you ask for?"
     - Lori Goldman


When I was pregnant, all I craved were Caitlin's lemon red velvet cookies. They hit the spot every time like nothing else could!

     - Caitlin Monahan

Caitlin made the cutest Halloween cookies as a thank you for all the doctors, nurses, and office staff at my OBGYN office after I had my son this October. The fondant work was impeccable and the details made them absolutely adorable. They were individually vacuumed sealed and packaged nicely. The entire office was very impressed! I’ve also had the opportunity to sample her cookies and chocolates. I haven’t tasted anything I didn’t like. I will definitely be ordering from Caitlin again.

     - Erica Kozma

I can’t thank Caitlin enough for her customer service and quality work. The woodland themed cookies she made for my sister’s baby shower were the talk of the party. Not only were they absolutely adorable, but they tasted great as well. I wouldn’t think twice about recommending Cafe Everyday Sunday for any special treats you may need.

     - Jennifer Berta


The cookies I ordered for a wedding shower were BEAUTIFUL! Cafe Everyday Sunday was able to work with my timeline and everything arrived looking perfect. The individual bags and pretty ribbon were a great touch as well!

     - Jennifer Ross MacLeod

I was so excited to try Caitlin's cookies! We ordered cookies for my daughters 3rd Birthday and they were amazing! Caitlin had put together the characters from "Frozen". They were perfect! They came individually wrapped with a bow. We used these cookies as favors for the kids. Thank you again for making my daughters birthday so special and tasty!

     - Candace Sninsky

Caitlin made my two-year-old a fabulous mix of Mickey Mouse and Paw Patrol cookies for her birthday. You can truly see the amount of time and talent that went into each one... so impressive! And then on top of that they were delicious!

     - Mary Olson

Absolutely amazing cookies and Rice Krispies pops! Everyone raved about how beautiful and great they were and asked who made them. And the process from beginning to end was great!!! From ordering, shipping, paying, and once they came were sealed with freshness. Can’t wait to order for our next birthday party!!!

     - Ashley Stevens

We have had a wonderful experience! The cookies arrived wonderfully packed and beautiful!
When we had the event the cookies were the talk of the party! They are a must have for anyone wanting to have a specialized cookie design!

      - Karie Striplin

Caitlin was fantastic to work with, and the cookies I ordered not only looked amazing, they tasted great too! I highly recommend Cafe Everyday Sunday, and will definitely be ordering again in the future!

     - Erika Schamus

Cafe Everyday Sunday has done a amazing job once again. My daughter requested Paw Patrol cookies for her Pink Party and when we opened the box she was beyond excited! They were detailed perfect and finished off with a Pink Bow to match. Thanks Caitlin!!

     - Jaime Zoroya

Caitlin's cookies are to die for! I ordered some for Christmas this year and her Italian Peach cookies were so good that I didn't want to share! Very fast delivery right to my door and FRESH! I can't wait to place my next order!

     - Tami Galitsis

These baked goods are beautiful and tasty! I highly recommend them!

     - Kristine Taylor

bottom of page